Feedback phrase decoder
Feedback at work arrives in shorthand. The shorthand and the actual problem are usually about different things, and acting on the words as given sends you at the wrong one. Find the phrase you were handed.
Each page says what the phrase usually means, what else it can mean, what to find out, and what the research does and does not support. Free, no account.
The Room — “I had the answer. The meeting ended before I said it.”
-
“Work on your executive presence.”
Something in the first seconds reads as uncertainty to people who have not worked with you. It is rarely about competence.
-
“Speak up more.”
A timing observation wearing a personality note. The point was ready; the window was not.
-
“Work on your communication.”
A signal you send is being read as something you did not mean. The fix is usually one habit, not your English.
-
“Be more confident.”
You are being read as less sure than you are. That is about a few observable habits, not your nerve.
-
“Get to the point faster.”
The conclusion is arriving after the room has stopped listening for it.
-
“You need to push back more.”
Someone wants to hear you disagree. Whether it is safe to depends on who, where and how.
-
“You come across as a bit direct.”
The content was fine. The delivery broke a rule the room does not say out loud.
-
“You seem disengaged on calls.”
Your silence on a call is being read as a trait, not a circumstance.
The Record — “I did the work. Someone else got the credit.”
-
“Be more visible.”
The people who decide about you cannot describe your work without asking someone else first.
-
“You need to sell yourself more.”
Your work is not reaching the people who decide. Louder self-promotion is not the only way to fix that, and often not the best.
-
“Keep me more in the loop.”
Your manager is being asked about your work and cannot answer without asking you first.
-
“It wasn’t clear what your contribution was.”
The work was shared. The credit was not split by who did what.
The Ladder — “I asked what's holding back my promotion. The answer is always vague.”
-
“Be more strategic.”
Your work is being read as execution rather than judgement. Nobody has watched you name a trade-off.
-
“You're not ready yet.”
There is a specific missing thing. Either the person does not know what it is, or cannot tell you.
-
“There’s no headcount right now.”
Three sentences in one: a timing problem, a structural one, or a polite no. The words do not tell you which.
-
“Keep doing what you’re doing.”
You are rated well on the job you have. Nobody is building the case for the next one.
-
“You need more exposure to senior leaders.”
The people who will argue about your promotion do not know you well enough to argue for you.
-
“Let’s revisit it next cycle.”
The decision for this cycle is already made. The next one starts being made earlier than you think.
-
“You are a strong performer, but we are not sure about your potential.”
Two different ratings are being kept on you. You are doing well on the one you can see.
-
“You should find a mentor.”
Often a way of passing on a problem the manager cannot solve. The help that moves careers is usually someone arguing for you in a room.
-
“Take on a stretch assignment.”
A stretch only counts if the people deciding about you can see how it went.
-
“Build more relationships across the business.”
Decisions about you are being made by people who know you only by name.
The Cost — “I'm carrying too much, and it's wearing me down.”
-
“You need better boundaries.”
Often said about a load that is structural. Whether a boundary costs you depends on whether anyone can see it.
-
“Be more of a team player.”
Often said after a no. It can be a fair note, or a charge for refusing work nobody else would take.
-
“We need you to be more flexible on hours.”
The time zones decide who stays late. This is often a structural load being described as an attitude.