In a meta-analysis of about 140 studies, supervisor support had essentially no relationship with promotion. Training and skill development had the strongest.
The paper, by Ng, Eby, Sorensen and Feldman, appeared in Personnel Psychology in 2005. Every finding in it is correlational, and reverse causation is plausible throughout: people already marked for promotion are the ones given the stretch assignments and the training. The meta-analysis could not sort samples by whether the workplace rewards open contests or sponsored moves, and it has no breakout for Asia-Pacific. It describes patterns across many careers. It does not say what will move yours.
What was and was not related to promotion
The numbers are correlations, not percentages. A correlation of .23 does not mean 23 percent of anything.
Training and skill development came out at .23, based on six studies and 6,503 people, the strongest of the organisational factors the authors examined. Social capital came in at .15, hours worked at .13, career sponsorship at .12. Education was .05. Supervisor support was .02, which was not statistically significant.
Read plainly: across these studies, the people who were promoted were more likely to be the ones who had been given real development, and no more likely to be the ones whose managers described themselves as supportive.
Career sponsorship, at .12, sits close to hours. The two are not the same thing: sponsorship means someone with influence is actively moving your case, while support is how the relationship feels.
The authors do not claim that support is useless, and the study does not test whether a supportive manager helps in other ways. The result is narrower than the headline makes it sound.
A moment this lands in
You ask your manager what is holding back your promotion. The answer is kind. Your manager says they value you, that you are doing well, that the team is lucky to have you. You leave feeling warmly regarded and entirely uninformed.
If you were raised to read warmth from a superior as a sign of standing, this can feel like good news. Nobody who thinks poorly of you speaks that way. Months later, the promotion goes to someone else, and the warmth looks, in hindsight, like a different thing from what you took it for.
The research does not say your manager was insincere. It says warmth, measured as support, was a poor guide to who moved up. A manager can be entirely on your side and still have no say over who gets stretch work, and no way of describing what the next level looks like.
What to notice
Notice whether the feedback you receive points at a kind of work. Training, a new scope, an assignment you have not done before — these were the closest the study came to a signal. A conversation that stays on how you are regarded, and never on what you could be given, is describing the relationship, not the route.
Notice who has been given the work that looks like the next level. The study cannot say whether that work caused the promotion or marked who was already on the path. Either way, it tells you where the path is.
Notice, too, how much of your effort is going into hours. They showed a weaker relationship than development did. That is an observation about averages, and it does not say hours do not matter in your firm.
One more point sits underneath this. In many places people learn that a good record speaks for itself and that asking for development is close to asking for a favour. Here, requests for specific assignments are often an ordinary part of how careers get shaped. That is an expectation worth checking, not something this study tested.
What stays yours
The study gives you a different first question. Not "does my manager like me," but "what has been given to the people who moved up, and have I been offered any of it?"
The answer will not tell you why you were passed over. It will tell you whether the vague answer you got is about you at all, or about a conversation that was never going to be specific.