Grabner, Künneke and Moers studied what happened at one international professional services firm after it began rating employees on explicit potential, a judgement of how far someone could go, separate from how well they were doing now.

Promotion decisions got worse. People promoted afterwards performed 0.190 points lower, on a five-point scale, in their new role. And the potential ratings predicted performance in the current job, but not in the new one.

The limits matter. One firm. 4,429 employee-year observations. First-year performance in the new role only, rated subjectively. It does not show that every company's potential ratings fail, or that yours does. It shows that in one place, a rating built to forecast the next job did not.

Read it slowly, because it explains something people have been told is their own fault.

The answer that is always vague

You ask what is standing between you and the next level. You get something with the texture of fog. More strategic. Broader presence. Not quite ready yet.

If you were raised to take feedback seriously and act on it exactly, this is maddening. You wanted a list. You would have done the list.

Here is a reading, and it is an inference from the study, not a finding in it. Where a firm rates potential, a manager is not reporting on what you did. They are forecasting what you might do in a role neither of you has held. A forecast has no receipts. There is nothing concrete to hand you, because the thing being judged has not happened yet.

So the vagueness may not be evasion. It may be the honest sound of someone describing an instrument that does not produce specifics.

That does not make it fair. It makes it legible.

Why the rating can matter and still be unreliable

The uncomfortable part of the Grabner study is that both things can be true at once. The rating can shape who is promoted, and it can be a poor predictor of who does well.

You are not learning a good test. You are learning the rules of the game that is actually being played. Those two things are separate, and treating them as one is how people end up either dismissing the rating as nonsense or rebuilding themselves around it.

Neither follows. A rating can be flawed and still be the thing in the room.

There is a second reading worth holding. Potential ratings, in this study, tracked how people were doing in the job they already had. That fits a common pattern: strong current performance gets read as potential, since it is the nearest thing a rater can see. Where that happens, how visible your current work is to the person doing the rating becomes part of the story. The study did not test that. It is a reason to ask the question, not an answer to it.

What to notice

You cannot see the rating. You can see what your manager says about you, and how.

Is the feedback about what happened, or what you are? Comments tied to a specific piece of work are a record. Comments about presence, polish, or readiness describe an impression of a future. Both are real. They need different responses, and mixing them up is how people spend a year fixing the wrong thing.

Does the vagueness shift when you ask about a specific moment? A manager who stays foggy about your next level may be quite concrete about one meeting, one document, one decision. If so, the specifics exist. They are filed somewhere other than the answer you were given.

Who else forms a view? A forecast gets built from several people's impressions. Whose voice is in yours is worth knowing, and it is rarely the one you assumed.

The limit on all of this

None of it tells you what your company rates, or whether it rates potential at all. Many do not use a formal scale. The study is about one firm that did.

What it gives you is a reason to stop reading the fog as a verdict on your ability. The question that follows is a better one: what, exactly, is being forecast, and by whom. The answer to that is local. It is worth finding out.